[thom3]

They're the same price though for the same diamond.

[Love2love7]

It depends what's her style like. Is she more classy and conservative? or more stylish and edgy?

I would say Cartier (my own personal choice) because I love their style. It's more up to date. But I also know girls love saying "It's Tiffany's".

It's YOUR choice.

[Malenfant]

I say Cartier. more exclusive, more stylish. 4 prong setting much more modern and clean than a 6 prong.

but either way she'll love it (but I say go with Carhills' suggestion!)

[thom3]

Photos:

Cartier profile:
http://www.pricescope.com/idealbb/files/cartier3333.jpg

Cartier on hand:
http://www.pricescope.com/idealbb/fi...5697_9907.jpeg

Tiffany profile:
http://www.pricescope.com/idealbb/files/tiffany%202.jpg

[Star Gazer]

Yup, I still vote Cartier. I really love 4-prongs on a round stone.

[Star Gazer]

Note though, that none of those pictures are 1 carat. Those are much larger.

[thom3]

Yeah the Tiffany in the photo is 1.2, the Cartier in the photos is 1.5

[Star Gazer]

Here's some more views of the Cartier:

http://www.pricescope.com/idealbb/fi...%20by%20LE.jpg

[Star Gazer]

Originally Posted by thom3

Yeah the Tiffany in the photo is 1.2, the Cartier in the photos is 1.5

There is NO WAY the Tiffany picture is only 1.2. I call impossible. That looks like almost 2 carats to me.

1.5 on the Cartier seems about right for the first picture, but absolutely not the second. The second picture also looks like 2+ carats to me.

[thom3]

Here is a .28 carat Tiffany, notice how unobtrusive the prongs are compared to other generic Tiffany-like settings.

http://www.pricescope.com/idealbb/files/ERING288.JPG