Jump to content

Girl asks me why I got her a gift for Xmas. How to respond?


While the thread author can add an update and reopen discussion, this thread was last posted in over a month ago. Want to continue the conversation? Feel free to start a new thread instead!

Recommended Posts

Posted

Hi,

 

A new girl that I like and she likes me too asked why I got her a Xmas gift..she was so suprised. What is the best way to respond in a cavalier way? Thanks

 

Chips

Posted

You don't know why you gave her the gift?

 

You're a nice guy and you hope to woo her with presents. That's why you did it. Meanwhile, she'll be pining over some bastard who treats her like crap. Then she'll make threads on LS saying, "A guy called Chipsnsalsa gave me a Christmas gift. Even though he's kinda creepy, he's a really sweet guy. But I just don't feel any chemistry toward him. But there's this really hot guy named Jeff who is a bit of a jerk and he ignores me but my attraction toward him is through the roof. How do I get with Jeff while rejecting Chipsnsalsa nicely?"

 

Serious though, man, ask for the gift back. Don't give gifts to women you're not related to unless you've banged them.

  • Author
Posted
You don't know why you gave her the gift?

 

You're a nice guy and you hope to woo her with presents. That's why you did it. Meanwhile, she'll be pining over some bastard who treats her like crap. Then she'll make threads on LS saying, "A guy called Chipsnsalsa gave me a Christmas gift. Even though he's kinda creepy, he's a really sweet guy. But I just don't feel any chemistry toward him. But there's this really hot guy named Jeff who is a bit of a jerk and he ignores me but my attraction toward him is through the roof. How do I get with Jeff while rejecting Chipsnsalsa nicely?"

 

Serious though, man, ask for the gift back. Don't give gifts to women you're not related to unless you've banged them.

 

Woo her with presents? I don't know if you are a Christain or not, but for your information Christmas is about giving.. i.e. Jesus gave his life for ours. Right?! I gave the gift because she is poor and didn't really get anything for Xmas.. smart ass. So I've said my piece... Oh and by the way, I don't just bang girls... I actually have to like them to sleep with them... it is called CLASS.. go back to school and get some. Cheers!!

Posted

It sounds like you already know how to respond to her question. Why not tell her you gave her a gift in the spirit of Christmas and because you think she is special. Shouldn't be more complicated than that.

Posted
Woo her with presents? I don't know if you are a Christain or not, but for your information Christmas is about giving.. i.e. Jesus gave his life for ours. Right?! I gave the gift because she is poor and didn't really get anything for Xmas.. smart ass. So I've said my piece... Oh and by the way, I don't just bang girls... I actually have to like them to sleep with them... it is called CLASS.. go back to school and get some. Cheers!!

 

Your post turned me on :love:

 

But honestly, never go all out until you've been dating a significant amount of time. But in the spirit of giving, a small gift is always appreciated ie chocolate, cute keychain.. Please no jewelry or anything fancy.

Posted
Woo her with presents? I don't know if you are a Christain or not, but for your information Christmas is about giving.. i.e. Jesus gave his life for ours. Right?! I gave the gift because she is poor and didn't really get anything for Xmas.. smart ass. So I've said my piece... Oh and by the way, I don't just bang girls... I actually have to like them to sleep with them... it is called CLASS.. go back to school and get some. Cheers!!

Look at this guy trying to pull the, "It's Christian thing to do" speech on me. My Dad is head minister of his church. I've been a Christian all my life (although I'm not really a very good one). And I can always smell BS from fellow Christians like a police dog sniffing cocaine in a junkie's dufflebag.

 

You have her a gift because she's poor? Are you sure the fact that she's cute doesn't have anything to do with it? Did you give a gift to every poor person you could find? Or do you only give gifts to cute girls?

 

How often do you give gifts to the poor? I doubt it's something you like to do regularly. I'm damn sure the fact that she was a cute girl was the excuse for giving her a gift. If she was a toothless old hag or a man, you wouldn't have been so obliged to give her a gift. Am I right, salsaboy?

Posted

Why do you want to hide that you like this girl.

 

The gift was for two reasons. One its Christmas - I'm sure you meant it for the holiday. Two you like this girl.

 

Nothing wrong with that, nothing to be ashamed of.

 

I would just say exactly the reason you gave it to her.

 

Otherwise she'll be in the dark about the real reason you gave it to her.

 

Also, maybe she knows you like her and just wants to hear you say the words.

 

Ok, she may reject you. That is a possibility and you want to hide it for now until you get to know her more.

 

Sure, then be cavalier until you are ready. Just say I got gifts for lots of people for example.

  • Author
Posted
Look at this guy trying to pull the, "It's Christian thing to do" speech on me. My Dad is head minister of his church. I've been a Christian all my life (although I'm not really a very good one). And I can always smell BS from fellow Christians like a police dog sniffing cocaine in a junkie's dufflebag.

 

You have her a gift because she's poor? Are you sure the fact that she's cute doesn't have anything to do with it? Did you give a gift to every poor person you could find? Or do you only give gifts to cute girls?

 

How often do you give gifts to the poor? I doubt it's something you like to do regularly. I'm damn sure the fact that she was a cute girl was the excuse for giving her a gift. If she was a toothless old hag or a man, you wouldn't have been so obliged to give her a gift. Am I right, salsaboy?

 

Hey Dufus... the only reason you can smell BS is because you are full of it and you present yourself on this forum like DOG. Put that in your crack pipe and smoke it. How often do I give to the poor? As MUCH AS POSSIBLE. It is written that GOD LOVES THE POOR.. and I am loyal to my Captain. I am not obliged to give anyone anything, I do it because I WANT to, ugly or not... its called the Spirit of Love..get that through your thick skull. One of these days, you may be the one without teeth on the street Spanky... Cheers!!

Posted
Hey Dufus... the only reason you can smell BS is because you are full of it and you present yourself on this forum like DOG. Put that in your crack pipe and smoke it. How often do I give to the poor? As MUCH AS POSSIBLE. It is written that GOD LOVES THE POOR.. and I am loyal to my Captain. I am not obliged to give anyone anything, I do it because I WANT to, ugly or not... its called the Spirit of Love..get that through your thick skull. One of these days, you may be the one without teeth on the street Spanky... Cheers!!

 

Well, I think Oxy is being harsh, but I'm on his side too.

 

If you're not interested in this girl romantically, and just wanted to give her a present because she's poor, like you give presents to all the other poor people during this time of the year, then say, "This is what I do during Christmas, I like to give everyone gifts. Merry Christmas!"

 

Once she hear this, she will know that:

1) You are just a generous person

2) She's not special, and you gave gifts to a bunch of other people as well

 

She will be thankful, she will think you're a nice person, but she will also know you are not romantically interested in her.

 

If you are romantically interested in this girl, then Oxy is kind of right, you gave her a gift because you want something from her... to move forward/kick start a romantic association.

 

Giving presents to women that you're interested in but you have not been romantic with, is called "purchasing their affection"; you are using money to attempt to buy their attention.

 

If she likes you back (romantically), then it doesn't matter, you've already won. You can buy presents or not buy presents, your choice. As long as you don't drop the ball, you're good to go.

 

If she isn't interested in you romantically, not only did you not gain any ground and wasted your time/money, you've actually put the nail in the coffin. She will either immediately friendzone you because you are so sweet, or she will view you as someone in a socially inferior position, because you are sucking up to her with money -- women like men of high social status, just like men like pretty women -- and you've just went the wrong way.

 

So gift giving as a move, in the battlefield of "single and dating", only works in situations where gift giving isn't necessary. So personally, I reserve it for my family, friends, and loved ones. And also for charity purposes, i.e. off the battlefield of "single and dating".

 

If you're interested in this girl, it's a move that I personally wouldn't do. Whatever you want to accomplish could be accomplished better without a gift. But what's done is done.

 

I think she asked because she wants to know if your gift giving comes with romantic intentions. Like everything in dating, her position currently is ambiguous:

1) She likes you, so she wants to hear that you gave her a present because you like her, and this will kick off your dating

2) She doesn't like you, so she wants to make sure your gift giving is 100% platonic in nature

 

So your move now, is to declare your intent, because this gift giving as created confusion and ambiguity.

 

If you like her romantically, let her know, make your move NOW, hopefully it's situation #1, and you get a date. This "approach" could have been accomplished without the gift; it won't change her answer. Anyway good luck.

 

If you like her platonically only, then it's time to clear the confusion. You are just a nice fellow. If she likes you, she will be disappointed and back off. If she doesn't, she will breath a sigh of relief.

 

So pick your path. But make sure you pick a path that's true to what you want. And in the future, don't give gifts if it comes with romantic intent, unless you are already romantically involved.

Posted

fishtaco gets it. Brilliant post, by the way, fishtaco.

Posted (edited)
Woo her with presents? I don't know if you are a Christain or not, but for your information Christmas is about giving.. i.e. Jesus gave his life for ours. Right?! I gave the gift because she is poor and didn't really get anything for Xmas.. smart ass. So I've said my piece... Oh and by the way, I don't just bang girls... I actually have to like them to sleep with them... it is called CLASS.. go back to school and get some. Cheers!!

 

Please be quiet both of you and let me think...

 

OP... so you post on LS to ask us why you did it? Wasn't your explaination above a sufficient reason to her? Hmm because Jesus told you to? BAM BOOM WAM Johhny Wammy! :bunny::bunny::bunny:

 

What are you really trying to ask us and what are your REAL intentions buddy?

Edited by Pizzaman81
Posted

"I saw this present and I thought of you" is a pretty easy way to say it without hiding your true intent but also not saying it blatantly.

  • Author
Posted

Everyone, except for Dufus, thanks for the input. Cheers!!

Posted

Cheers!!! I hope it works out for you.

Posted

No one seems to have mentioned that the business world has spent a fortune (and consequently everyone here has heard thousands of commercials with this message) to convince people that they are supposed to give other people gifts on Christmas. Christmas gift giving is just a gimmick so business can make money.

Posted

What did you do when she asked you? Tell her you'd have to get back to her on that? :)

Posted
You don't know why you gave her the gift?

 

You're a nice guy and you hope to woo her with presents. That's why you did it. Meanwhile, she'll be pining over some bastard who treats her like crap. Then she'll make threads on LS saying, "A guy called Chipsnsalsa gave me a Christmas gift. Even though he's kinda creepy, he's a really sweet guy. But I just don't feel any chemistry toward him. But there's this really hot guy named Jeff who is a bit of a jerk and he ignores me but my attraction toward him is through the roof. How do I get with Jeff while rejecting Chipsnsalsa nicely?"

 

Serious though, man, ask for the gift back. Don't give gifts to women you're not related to unless you've banged them.

 

Sounds like the speech of an experienced man. OP, take out a pen. Your lesson begins...

Posted
Look at this guy trying to pull the, "It's Christian thing to do" speech on me. My Dad is head minister of his church. I've been a Christian all my life (although I'm not really a very good one). And I can always smell BS from fellow Christians like a police dog sniffing cocaine in a junkie's dufflebag.

 

You have her a gift because she's poor? Are you sure the fact that she's cute doesn't have anything to do with it? Did you give a gift to every poor person you could find? Or do you only give gifts to cute girls?

 

How often do you give gifts to the poor? I doubt it's something you like to do regularly. I'm damn sure the fact that she was a cute girl was the excuse for giving her a gift. If she was a toothless old hag or a man, you wouldn't have been so obliged to give her a gift. Am I right, salsaboy?

 

LMAO!!! I thought your previous post was hysterical - This one takes the cake.. Will you marry me?

  • Author
Posted
What did you do when she asked you? Tell her you'd have to get back to her on that? :)

 

No. Just kept it light, fun, and joked a little.. played it down like no big deal... all in all I just said something along the lines it's Christmas and you are special :) Simple. I mean, to me, the last thing I want to say to a girl who I like and she likes me is "OH WOW, I REALLY LIKE YOU". Most clever girls can read between the lines... at least the ones I have dated...

 

Besides, liking someone is shown better by action, not words. A fabulous body and face are a dime a dozen.. I know more than a few... but show me a woman who has HEART and is not a phoney or flake... and I'll show you a keeper. That is my take.. Cheers!!

Posted

"Because now you owe me sex."

×
×
  • Create New...